Florida choose blocks subpoenas in migrant data struggle

Florida choose blocks subpoenas in migrant data struggle

TALLAHASSEE – A Leon County circuit choose has rejected subpoenas that sought to pressure two high aides to Gov. Ron DeSantis to testify in a public-records lawsuit stemming from controversial flights of migrants to Martha’s Winery in Massachusetts.

Decide J. Lee Marsh issued a two-page choice Sunday that quashed subpoenas the Florida Heart for Authorities Accountability had issued to DeSantis Chief of Employees James Uthmeier and Larry Keefe, a public-safety adviser to the governor. Marsh additionally shielded Chris DeLorenz, a data custodian within the governor’s workplace, from testifying.

Marsh dominated after the DeSantis administration filed a movement late Thursday searching for to dam the subpoenas, which had been issued by the Florida Heart for Authorities Accountability. The subpoenas sought to pressure testimony in a listening to Tuesday within the public-records lawsuit filed towards the administration by the middle, an open-government group.

The ruling agreed with DeSantis administration arguments that Uthmeier and Keefe shouldn’t be required to testify due to what is named the “apex doctrine,” a authorized idea that usually shields high-ranking officers from testifying if info might be obtained in different methods. Marsh wrote that the administration offered “declarations explaining that Mr. Uthmeier and Mr. Keefe lack distinctive, private data of the problems being litigated.”

“As well as, the courtroom finds that plaintiff has not met its burden as a result of taking the testimony of Mr. Keefe and Mr. Uthmeier isn’t crucial for this public data lawsuit,” Marsh wrote.

Additionally, Marsh wrote that the subpoena for DeLorenz was “an annoyance, oppressive and an undue burden” beneath a authorized rule.

“The courtroom won’t set the precedent that EOG’s (the Government Workplace of the Governor’s) data custodian could also be haled into courtroom and not using a good religion foundation to contest his declaration,” wrote Marsh, who held an emergency listening to Friday on the movement to quash the subpoenas.

The Florida Heart for Authorities Accountability filed the lawsuit Oct. 10 and alleged that the governor’s workplace didn’t adjust to requests to launch a collection of data concerning the flights, which carried about 50 migrants from Texas to Massachusetts and drew nationwide consideration. The middle issued subpoenas final week.

The lawsuit, partially, sought data, telephone logs or textual content logs that would present communications by Uthmeier concerning the flights. Additionally, it sought any data that might present communications with Texas Gov. Greg Abbott’s workplace about relocating migrants.

The DeSantis administration launched some data, however the middle stated within the lawsuit that the discharge was not “responsive” to requests made Sept. 20 and Sept. 21 beneath Florida’s public-records legislation. Additionally, Andrea Flynn Mogensen, an lawyer for the middle, despatched an e-mail to DeLorenz on Oct. 17 that stated the administration had not offered things like a textual content log and a telephone log for Uthmeier, in line with a doc filed Friday within the case.

“We reviewed the (data) manufacturing and didn’t see any log of textual content messages despatched or obtained by Mr. Uthmeier,” Mogensen wrote within the Oct. 17 e-mail. “If we now have ignored something please tell us.”

The middle additionally has filed a separate public-records lawsuit towards the Florida Division of Transportation and Vertol Techniques Firm, Inc., which obtained a state contract to move migrants. That lawsuit stays pending.

The 2 flights on Sept. 14 carried migrants from Texas to Massachusetts, with a cease at an airport within the Northwest Florida group of Crestview. The DeSantis administration tapped into $12 million that the Legislature offered to move undocumented immigrants. A part of the controversy facilities on Florida flying migrants from Texas.

Quite a few media reviews have stated Keefe, a former United States lawyer in North Florida, performed a behind-the-scenes function within the flights. DeSantis, broadly talked about as a possible 2024 Republican presidential candidate, often blasts the Biden administration’s immigration insurance policies. He additionally has criticized “sanctuary” communities, corresponding to Martha’s Winery.

Leave a Reply