N.W.T. Supreme Court docket quashes search warrant for Lutsel Ok’e tradition camp

N.W.T. Supreme Court docket quashes search warrant for Lutsel Ok’e tradition camp
N.W.T. Supreme Court docket quashes search warrant for Lutsel Ok’e tradition camp

The tradition camp at Timber Bay. About 80 Łutsel Ok’e Dene First Nation members had been participating in a tradition camp on the lake when wildlife officers executed what the First Nation describes as an ‘invasive’ seek for illegally hunted caribou. (Submitted by Iris Catholique – picture credit score)

The search warrant that allowed N.W.T. wildlife officers to gather caribou samples from a Łutsel Ok’e tradition camp has been quashed in courtroom.

Supreme Court docket Justice Shannon Smallwood threw out the warrant Monday morning after Larry Innes, the defence counsel for Łutsel Ok’e Dene First Nation, utilized to have it quashed. Neither of the legal professionals for the territorial authorities, Roger Shepard and Maren Zimmer, objected.

“The very fact we’re right here is in itself an issue. This warrant ought to have by no means been issued, this search ought to have by no means taken place, so we’re cleansing up after the very fact,” Innes informed reporters after the listening to.

Jenna Dulewich/CBC

Jenna Dulewich/CBC

‘Vindication’, says lawyer

The approval for the search warrant to be quashed reveals “vindication” for Łutsel Ok’e’s place, Innes stated.

“They didn’t contest our software and agreed that the warrant was issued with out authority,” he stated of the territorial authorities.

Final month, the First Nation demanded an apology after a “forceful invasion” that they described as “invasive,” “aggressive and disrespectful.”

The First Nation stated wildlife officers helicoptered right into a camp on Artillery Lake on Sept. 13 and spent hours looking out household tents and teepees.

Wildlife officers had been investigating unlawful caribou harvesting inside a cellular no-hunting zone that follows the Bathurst caribou herd to guard it from hunters. They’d discovered the carcasses of 10 caribou with vital quantities of meat nonetheless on them.

Information of the occasion, which the First Nation described as a “raid,” introduced condemnation of officers’ actions from different organizations. Dene Nationwide Chief Gerald Antoine referred to as for the resignation of officers who directed and supported the search, and Tu Nedhé-Wiilideh MLA Richard Edjericon demanded an apology and investigation.

Submitted by Environment and Natural Resources

Submitted by Atmosphere and Pure Sources

CBC North has requested an interview with Atmosphere and Pure Sources Minister Shane Thompson concerning the courtroom choice.

Shortly after the raid, Thompson issued a press release saying officers had obtained two impartial reviews from members of the general public about unlawful harvesting.

Later within the month, the Division of Atmosphere and Pure Sources stated it might be looking for an exterior overview of officers’ actions.

Civil case may very well be subsequent

The matter took lower than 20 minutes within the territorial courtroom as Choose Smallwood listened to the submission.

Territorial lawyer Shepard stated any samples seized through the search could be forfeited and any individual wishing to acquire their seized caribou can undergo the Wildlife Act.

Now that the search warrant has been “declared illegal” in courtroom, Innes stated there shall be discussions locally on what occurs subsequent, hinting at civil pursuits.

“Subsequent step is taking a look at civil treatments — successfully a lawsuit towards the minister for having invaded the privateness and violating the rights of the folks at camp,” he stated.

If the First Nation was to proceed with the lawsuit, which the defence lawyer stated he thinks there are robust grounds for, they might search damages for breach of particular person privateness, sense of safety and cultural dignity.

Leave a Reply